Re-thinking Lyra (the movie)

I posted this on Child_lit and thought that it should be here as well. I don’t want to prevent people from going to see the movie. So much of it is done right and beautifully. It will be a shame if it doesn’t reach a large audience!

After almost a week — I finally have to come to terms with my own
inability to judge this movie. I plan on seeing it again, putting
aside my pre-conceived notions on what the movie should have been and
just see it as it IS — a movie based on a book… a book that I have
come to love and treasure more and more, the longer it lives in my

I have posted on my online journal the initial reactions from me and
the group of teens who went to the movie with me. And on Monday, I
had a chance to talk to a group of 6th graders who saw the movie over
the weekend. Here’s the link of the school blog recording what they
had to say:

What warms my heart is the level of intensity in the discussion over
this adaptation — they have a LOT a LOT to say and they say with
conviction and passion — they know ALL the details in the book and
they want the movie to convey every single important element in the
book — and the elements they care about are not just action and plot.
They care about the rendition of the characters; the relationships
between the characters; the “hidden” messages; the importance of
minute moments; the pacing and story form; the struggle between the
light and the dark; and the ambiguity of the characters and their
actions. It is truly satisfying to hear these young readers take the
book so seriously and so much to heart. I think it is cause for

Now, if I don’t have to read so many new books for my Notables duty,
I’ll be re-reading the book! I’ll do what Monica’s been doing —
listening to it soon.

1 Comment

Filed under Child_lit Archive

One response to “Re-thinking Lyra (the movie)

  1. Anonymous

    i really enjoyed reading the goldan compass, and am verry excited to hear that they are making it into a movie!!!! :)

    An Edinger Stunant


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.